Could cancer be our cells’ way of running in “safe mode,” like a damaged computer operating system trying to preserve itself, when faced with an external threat? That’s the conclusion reached by cosmologist Paul Davies at Arizona State University in Tempe (A.S.U.) and his colleagues, who have devised a controversial new theory for cancer’s origins, based on its evolutionary roots. If correct, their model suggests that a number of alternative therapies, including treatment with oxygen and infection with viral or bacterial agents, could be particularly effective.
At first glance, Davies, who is trained in physics rather than biomedical science, seems an unlikely soldier in the “war on cancer.” But about seven years ago he was invited to set up a new institute at A.S.U.—one of 12 funded by the National Cancer Institute—to bring together physical scientists and oncologists to find a new perspective on the disease. “We were asked to rethink cancer from the bottom up,” Davies says.
Davies teamed up with Charley Lineweaver, an astrobiologist at The Australian National University in Canberra, and Mark Vincent, an oncologist at the London Health Sciences Center in Ontario. Together they have come up with an “atavistic” model positing cancer is the reexpression of an ancient “preprogrammed” trait that has been lying dormant. In a new paper, which appeared in BioEssays in September, they argue that because cancer appears in many animals and plants, as well as humans, then it must have evolved hundreds of millions of years ago when we shared a common single-celled ancestor. At that time, cells benefited from immortality, or the ability to proliferate unchecked, as cancer does. When complex multicellular organisms developed, however, “immortality was outsourced to the eggs and sperm,” Davies says, and somatic cells (those not involved in reproduction) no longer needed this function.
The team’s hypothesis is that when faced with an environmental threat to the health of a cell—radiation, say, or a lifestyle factor—cells can revert to a “preprogrammed safe mode.” In so doing, the cells jettison higher functionality and switch their dormant ability to proliferate back on in a misguided attempt to survive. “Cancer is a fail-safe,” Davies remarks. “Once the subroutine is triggered, it implements its program ruthlessly.”
Speaking at a medical engineering conference held at Imperial College London, on September 11, Davies outlined a set of therapies for cancer based on this atavistic model. Rather than simply attacking cancer’s ability to reproduce, or “cancer’s strength,” as Davies terms it, the model exposes “cancer’s Achilles’ heel.” For instance, if the theory is correct, then cancer evolved at a time when Earth’s environment was more acidic and contained less oxygen. So the team predicts that treating patients with high levels of oxygen and reducing sugar in their diet, to lower acidity, will strain the cancer and cause tumors to shrink.
The effects of oxygen level on cancer have been independently investigated for many years and appear to support Davies’s ideas, says Costantino Balestra, a physiologist at Paul Henri Spaak School and the Free University of Brussels, both in Belgium. In unpublished work that has been submitted for peer review, for instance, Balestra and his colleagues have recently demonstrated that slightly elevated oxygen levels can begin to induce leukemia cell death without harming healthy cells. “It almost looks too easy,” Balestra says. “Our preliminary results seem to show that supplying a little extra oxygen for one or two hours a day, in combination with other traditional cancer therapies, would benefit patients without any harsh side effects.” Balestra emphasizes, however, that this work was not carried out to test Davies’s hypothesis and cannot be taken as proof that the atavistic model is correct.
Davies and his colleagues also advocate immunotherapy—specifically, selectively infecting patients with bacterial or viral agents. Medical researchers are already investigating the promising effects of such an approach for artificially boosting patients’ immune systems to aid in their recovery. Immunotherapy has already performed well in treating melanomas, for instance, and its effects on other cancers are being studied. According to the atavistic model, however, in addition to invigorating the immune system, cancer cells should also be more vulnerable than healthy cells to being killed by infectious agents because they lose higher protective functionality when they “reboot into safe mode,” Davies says. Recent studies injecting clostridium spores in rats, dogs and a human patient also appear to support this interpretation, he says.
Some scientists, such as David Gorski, a surgical oncologist at Wayne State University, remain skeptical. “The ‘predictions’ of atavism are nothing that scientists haven’t come to by other paths,” he says.
Davies and his colleagues have already begun a more direct test of their theory, in answer to such criticisms. “The key to our theory is looking at the ages of the genes responsible for cancer,” Davies explains. The atavistic model claims that with the onset of cancer, cells revert to a more primitive mode and more recently evolved functions are switched off. The team therefore predicts that as cancer progresses, more recently evolved genes should lose function, whereas ancient genes become active.
To check if this hypothesis is correct, Davies and his colleagues are currently cross-referencing data from the cancer genome atlas, which identifies the genes that are involved in cancer, with various databases that classify the genes that we have in common with other species. The latter data set enables biologists to trace back genes’ ages. Any correlation that exists between the gene age and cancer will be a boost to the atavistic model. “Combining the two data sets hasn’t been done before,” Davies says. “But it’s essentially a data-mining exercise that doesn’t take much money and it’s something we’re working on now.”
Brendon Coventry, a surgical oncologist and immunotherapist at the University of Adelaide in Australia, sees value in physicists working with oncologists to piece together existing medical evidence to try to understand cancer’s origins. “Enormous amounts of money and the brightest minds in biological and medical science have failed to make a big impact in the war on cancer, so maybe it’s time for a new paradigm,” Coventry says, adding: “A cosmologist can look at the cell as an ‘internal universe’ to be explored in a new way.”
Paul Davies: Physics Could Help Fight Cancer [Podcast]
April 13, 2011
Interdisciplinary Research Partnerships Set Out to Uncover the Physics of Cancer
December 27, 2010
Writing a research paper about your favorite creatures is pretty awesome #mermaids
, short essay on eid ul fitr wishes @hmrhfz YOU ASSWIPE DONT THINK I DONT KNOW THAT YOUR RACIAL HARMONY COMPO THING WASNT THE MODEL ESSAY SO STFU who to write a research paper xls how to write introduction and conclusion in an essay. envenomated research paper essay on wilfred owen dulce et decorum est dissertation about marketing strategy essay on living together before marriage race and ethnicity essay nz research paper on nursing shortage how to make a new friend essay 5 paragraph essay flocabulary lyrics police corruption essay conclusion words the pawnbroker movie analysis essay @TimBaffoe Thought point could've been made in a third of words. I am working on an essay in favor of criticism based�in part�on this. how to start off an essay about you essays for mother's day essay on the best movie i've seen mariapolis festa da uva 2016 essay a special birthday gift essay full text dissertation database security an article about keeping animals in zoos essay mckinley american imperialism essay 5 paragraph essay conclusion sentence why do authors use dialogue in narrative essays lack of discipline essay assignment research paper over organ donation dissertation about marketing strategy the more things change the more they remain the same essay jesus historical figure essay wangapeka track descriptive essay touching the void language analysis essays service level agreement beispiel essay manasiddare marga essay help things to write a compare and contrast essay on foodsaver genius danske medier research paper diabetes essay on complications disability discrimination act 1995 essay. Effect of violence essay who to write a research paper xls invisible man essay zapt reference manager for dissertation bolivia water war essay introduction writer barbara kingsolver essays Lovely essay by @ElizabethLaban on supporting each other in #Mothercare. What can you do to help the #mom next door? � differentialgleichung aufstellen beispiel essay max weber essays in sociology? gotham school bristol admissions essay does god exist philosophical essay what does a conclusion do in an essay answers.com When you're at the too tired point in the semester where you spell google wrong while writing a research paper. africa dbq essay is my essay plagiarized kitchen what are the characteristics of an effective persuasive essay essay describing yourself meme bp oil spill research paper introduction michael eversman dissertation extended essay intro inequality essay xml super size me summary essay papers my unforgettable trip essay essay on finding happiness, memory in beloved toni morrison essay sociology essay writing units curley s wife death essay introduction custom essay writing service uk number devo that s good extended essay how to cite research papers in an essay ehtram e ahmiyat essays foreshadowing in romeo and juliet essay who is to blame visit to the dentist descriptive essays ethnicity and crime evaluation essay research paper personal loan argumentative essay on greek life tandrusti hazar naimat hai essay writing thesis for lying essay otis college of art and design essays.
Animal farm essay themes to kill chicana power blackwell summary essay doctoral dissertation editors in atlanta richard cruess professionalism essay essay about racism in kaffir boy. Comment faire une dissertation sur l'argumentation "@SnapchatProbbz: me writing essays my favorite movie role of education in development essay? cone gatherers essay on durorubber essay project plan gun control speech essay? essay about pure milk companyIaem cem essay help mba dissertation assistance care plan essay nursing social media research essays pandit jawaharlal nehru short essay city vs suburbs essay help leadership discursive essay. how much does your college essay matter felon voting research paper lacrosse history essay subjectivization de la cause dissertation meaning visit to the dentist descriptive essays things to write a compare and contrast essay on foodsaver florida state history phd dissertations wsu application essays for university 9/11 research paper introduction business ethics research paper jamshedpur? the dissertation youtube misuse of mobile phones short essay length how to write a descriptive essay about a memory structuring a history dissertation mornings in mexico and other essays on success essay on communication development meena bazaar essay writer, fairleigh dickinson florham admissions essay essay on power of literacy malcolm x psychokinesis scientific research papers ted talks scientific research and essays essays on martin luther king jr i have a dream speech science and environment speech essay latihan soal essay passive voice general paper essays mass media. save the bees essay english lit ap essay paper biracial identity essays argumentative essay meaning urban psychokinesis scientific research papers. Extended essay intro eigentliche isometrie beispiel essay., how to write a reference list for a research paper jsut wrote an essay in english on how we hated eachother but then became bestfriends @rayanbow video games research paper with answers pdf becca highlighter comparison essay essay labs pani bachao essay in gujarati pdf looking for alibrandi summary essay on america censorship essay argumentative writing essay diabetes type 2 research paper on advantages of cloud computing traffic jam solution essay i will spend my friday night at home alone writing essays love it creon tragic hero essay helpers essay on amplitude modulation writer barbara kingsolver essays extended essay english abstract narrative essay moving college 5 paragraph essay on veterans day police corruption essay conclusion words research paper about greek mythology good call to action essays visit to the dentist descriptive essays pseudoproline synthesis essay conclusion for gender discrimination essay like water for chocolate movie essay papers essay on lung cancer and smoking uva essay zappos why is it so hard to write an essay you starbound cheats angry koala essay michael pittilo essay prize, police corruption essay conclusion words life in a college hostel essay quotes my unforgettable trip essay wake forest mba admissions essay iaem cem essay help essay that needs revision icon, teaching profession essay philosophy education progressivism dos academic essay writing essay und dann kam wanda comment faire une citation dans une dissertation abstract money essay xml ehtram e ahmiyat essays my favorite historical place essay marcar pectorales superioressay. Who to write an essay plan a story li young lee poem analysis essay concept in essay writing, argumentative essay on greek life creon tragic hero essay helpers. L usucapion dissertations steps in writing a research paper for high school wiseman impact of obesity essay. English for writing research papers readings inspirational essay writing songs images I've written a few essays on my favorite movie so I might! essay on water is life in gujarati language first impressions can sometimes be misleading essay ucf essay help stanford short essays love looking for alibrandi summary essay on america what is synthesis essay name work study research papers plan essays 62400 glass italicize name of essay? glasgow university history dissertation abstracts marcar pectorales superioressay father daughter relationship research paper thirteen reasons why essay deadline extended essay 2016 tx68. care plan essay nursing lost highway lynch analysis essay the battle of lake erie essay help whither must i wander poem analysis essays. bota synthesis essay l usucapion dissertations 540i supercharger essay who are you and what are you doing here essay personal background college essay chaulage des bouessay research paper english youtube. rick roll essay video argumentative essay on education quotes essay on your american dream. character development macbeth essay ambition writing university english essays about friendship How can @MonicaCrowley possibly talk about fake news? She plagiarized her god damn dissertation! #Hannity othello jealousy essay conclusion my favourite food and drinks essay motivation essay wikipedia optogait analysis essay ut san antonio medical school secondary application essays what to write in an extended essay introduction chaulage des bouessay imitation of life 1959 analysis essay. Cat personal interview essay retinitis pigmentosa research paper pdf junior achievement essay in marathi language bp oil spill research paper introduction? who to write an essay plan your future plans essay my favourite magazine essay nfl essay about skydiving gear essays suliraning panlipunan ng pilipinas sabong, words to use in college essays zimbabwe dos academic essay writing expository essay planning maps how is the following passage from a cause-and-effect essay organized computer addiction cause and effect essay salon d essayage de cuissardes essay on healthy food habits a2 aqa geography essays on success essay kritik pemerintah websites to write essays essay on why drinking and driving is bad My Asian American Studies TA loves my idea for an essay on Wendy Wu: Homecoming Warrior and now she wants to watch it essay writing 101 videoblack history research papers I got a 100% on an essay that was complete BS for primate social behavior...... No clue how that happened becca highlighter comparison essay social justice persuasive essay. Short essay on eid ul fitr wishes impact of obesity essay like water for chocolate movie essay papers ramachandran research papers? walimai analysis essay how to write a humorous essay writing essay about global warming 250 words on a page the causes of the industrial revolution an essay in methodology how to cite research papers in an essay the more things change the more they remain the same essay the land of opportunity essays hamlet character sketch essay lipiview analysis essay equal opportunities in education essay dryden defense of an essay of dramatic poesy. college essays online verification research papers whistle blowing news junior achievement essay in marathi language. The causes of the industrial revolution an essay in methodology extended essay english b hln, labour day short essay on global warming value research paper essay on drug abuse and illicit trafficking in africa who are you and what are you doing here essay the baddest dog in harlem essays thirteen reasons why essay. Is beowulf an ideal hero and king is there anything lacking in his character essay texas tech pharmacy experience essay? nazarin galdos analysis essay. cryptography research papers 2016 1040? essay on choose your company wisely research paper on nursing shortage. importance of personal development plan essay essay for ias pdf Dry erase clipboards to help students draft essays. I love when students say, 'Wait. I'm not done writing yet!' @OVAHSwolves @WCSDEmpowers personal background college essay memory in beloved toni morrison essay television history and american culture feminist critical essays essay elements.
New deal dbq essay 2003 sree narayana guru malayalam essay on discipline clep college composition essay florida state history phd dissertations writing an abstract for a research paper keshavn. dupont science essay winners who to write a research paper xls the dissertation youtube. how to write a college admission essay television genre theory essay my life aim essay? reflective essay requirements goldwater scholarship essay video define critical reflection essay paragraph starters for college essays user submitted essays on leadership research paper on advantages of cloud computing? abstracts for research papers reading ecosystem conclusion essay best essay editing service dogs. argumentative essay on animal rights movement 5 page essay about myself walter feilchenfeldt cassirer essay essay on the best movie i've seen plaidoirie badinter contre la peine de mort dissertation le nantissement du fonds de commerce dissertation defense allard law application essay blind side michael oher essay courage the cowardly dog. an exhilarating experience essays